Skip to main content

Difference between Beam and Shell Model

Submitted by amitshah3333 on

Hello, I am trying to solve structural problem of loaded pipe structure in ANSYS.

I tried two method/way.

First I modelled pipe structure as BEAM element and defined the cross-section.

Secondly, I modelled the pipe structure as Shell element and defined thickness. 

Now during post-processing, I noticed very large deviation in shear force, axial force and bending moment (nearly 3 times more in BEAM model cmpr to SHELL model) 

Can anybody guide/help to rectify model and bring this deviation down? I dont want to go for Pipe element of ANSYS.

 

Thankyou,

Amit