A blog for discussing fracture papers
The aim of ESIS is not only to develop and
extend knowledge in all aspects of structural integrity, but also to disseminate this knowledge world-wide by means of scientific publications and to educate young engineers and scientists.
For these purposes, three Elsevier journals - Engineering Fracture Mechanics , Engineering Failure Analysis and
International Journal of Fatigue - are published in affiliation with ESIS.
Promoting and intensifying this aim is what we want to achieve through a new blog that ESIS will manage here for discussing some of the papers which appear in Engineering Fracture Mechanics. Its editors, Profs. Karl-Heinz Schwalbe and Tony Ingraffea,fully support this initiative.
ESIS hopes that this blog will achieve the following objectives:
- To start a scientific discussion on relevant topics
through comments by leading scientists (the chief ‘commenter’ will be
Prof. Wolfgang Brocks);
- To remind the authors of papers in EFM (and all the
fracture community) that perhaps they have forgotten something
important which was published in the past (perhaps in old books): the policy of ESIS is to make some of these books available on-line to ESIS members;
- To promote a real cross-citation of the papers and
a substantive discussion of ideas in a scenario where, in spite of the
easy on-line access to most journals, there is a serious tendency to
restrict the number of ‘external references’ and a snobbish tendency to
promote ‘auto-citations’ (to the same group, the same journal, the same
- To focus attention on new ideas that run the serious risk of not emerging from the noise of too much published “stuff”;
- To induce bloggers to communicate their opinions on a paper, in particular their interpretation of the research results, thus adding new thoughts to that paper. In addition, to promote excellence in publication in a scenario where deficiencies of a paper may not have been detected by the reviewers, simply due to the pressure of time the reviewers have to do their work.
The proposed rules of usage of this blog include:
- A group of leading scientists headed by Prof. W. Brocks will post onto this iMechanica
node comments and remarks to some of the papers published in EFM;
- The authors of the papers will receive a notification of the remarks by ESIS Webmaster and they will be invited to reply through a detailed document that will appear on the ESIS website;
- The replies will also be posted onto iMechanica by ESIS (so that the authors do not have to worry about technical details). Hopefully, we will receive further comments and questions by other scientists/practitioners.
To start, this blog will concentrate only on fracture papers; later other sections
devoted to fatigue and other sectors of structural integrity will be added.
If you like the idea, then post a comment and bookmark this iMechanica node. Shortly, as soon as we will have prepared all the technical details, we will be ‘on the air’.
S. Beretta & W. Brocks
ESIS Executive Committee