Amit Acharya's blog
A mathematician's take on "what is light?"
Submitted by Amit Acharya on Mon, 2012-01-30 01:26.Attached is an intriguing commentary on the scientific method through an example, written by my good friend, Luc Tartar. The specific example is that of trying to understand what 'light' might be, especially from a mathematician's point of view. The mathematician in this case is an extremely talented one, who also happens to actually understand a whole lot of physics and mechanics.
I am posting it especially for our younger members on imechanica, since I think there are interesting things to learn here. If you are an engineer or a physicist, it will not necessarily be a comfortable read, both on matters technical and philosophical. But my personal point of view is that not everything worth learning has to be within one's comfort zone. Being open-minded about learning, and recognizing when there is something to be learnt, is one of the best habits we can develop. One does not have to agree with all that is said, but the greatest intellectual progress happens when a collection of sincere, talented people operate at the boundary of their individual comfort zones - not necessarily agreeing, but definitely learning from each other.
So, enjoy!
- 8 comments
- Read more
- 1072 reads
Incomplete thoughts on mass flux and superposed RBM
Submitted by Amit Acharya on Sat, 2012-01-14 17:31.Attached are some (hand-written) observations on wanting to do continuum mechanics when mass is not conserved for fixed sets of particles of the body (so, situations transcending the rocket-losing-mass type). I feel (un)comfortable with these observations, depending upon the day I think about such things.
The primary reason to even consider this is I would like to explore if any physically realistic model can be made in dealing with damage and fracture without assuming that the topology of the mathematical body in 3-d Euclidean space is changed during a motion representative of damage evolution and fracture - of course, in 'reality' the topology changes (or so it seems), but then there are serious difficulties in setting up a *dynamical* model. I am interested in understanding the kinematical apsects of this question clearly as well as the dynamical ones (in this regard, I should mention that I have a reasonable understanding of what gets done in peridynamics and would still like to consider alternatives).
Perhaps someone on imechanica will straighten me out on these questions.
Anisotropic yield, plastic spin, and dislocation mechanics
Submitted by Amit Acharya on Sun, 2011-10-02 15:37.
(This paper is to appear in the IUTAM Procedia on "Linking scales in
computations: from microstructure to macro-scale properties," edited by
Oana Cazacu)
Amit Acharya, S. Jonathan Chapman
With a view towards utilization in macroscopic continuum models, an approximation to the root-mean-square of the driving force field on individual dislocations within a "representative volume element" is derived. The plastic flow field of individual dislocations is also similarly averaged. Even under strong simplifying assumptions, non-trivial results on the origin and nature of anisotropic macroscopic yielding, plastic spin, and the plastic flow rule (for single and polycrystalline bodies) are obtained. A particular result is the dependence of the plastic response of a material point of the averaged model on the presence of dislocations within it, an effect absent in conventional theories of plastic response (e.g., J2 plasticity). Also noteworthy is the explicit geometric accounting of the indeterminacy of the slip-plane identity of the screw dislocation that appears to lead to some differences with conventional ideas.
- 2 comments
- Read more
- 1332 reads
Coupled phase transformations and plasticity as a field theory of deformation incompatibility
Submitted by Amit Acharya on Tue, 2011-08-30 19:58.(to appear in International Journal of Fracture; Proceedings of the 5th Intl. Symposium on Defect andMaterial Mechanics)
Amit Acharya and Claude Fressengeas
The duality between terminating discontinuities of fields and the incompatibilities of their gradients is used to define a coupled dynamics of the discontinuities of the elastic displacement field and its gradient. The theory goes beyond standard translational and rotational Volterra defects (dislocations and disclinations) by introducing and physically grounding the concept of generalized disclinations in solids without a fundamental rotational kinematic degree of freedom (e.g. directors). All considered incompatibilities have the geometric meaning of a density of lines carrying appropriate topological charge, and a conservation argument provides for natural physical laws for their dynamics. Thermodynamic guidance provides the driving forces conjugate to the kinematic objects characterizing the defect motions, as well as admissible constitutive relations for stress and couple stress. We show that even though 'higher-order' kinematic objects are involved in the specific free energy, couple stresses may not be required in the mechanical description in particular cases. The resulting models are capable of addressing the evolution of defect microstructures under stress with the intent of understanding dislocation plasticity in the presence of phase transformation and grain boundary dynamics.
- 5 comments
- Read more
- 1979 reads
Time-averaged coarse variables for multiscale dynamics
Submitted by Amit Acharya on Tue, 2011-08-30 01:31.to appear in Quarterly of Applied Mathematics
by Marshall Slemrod and Amit Acharya
Given an autonomous system of Ordinary Diff erential Equations without an a priori split into slow and fast components, we defi ne a strategy for producing a large class of `slow' variables (constants of fast motion) in a precise sense. The equation of evolution of any such slow variable is deduced. The strategy is to rewrite our system on an in finite dimensional "history" Hilbert space X and defi ne our coarse observation as a functional on X.
On the three-dimensional Filon construct for dislocations
Submitted by Amit Acharya on Thu, 2011-04-14 15:27.
(to appear in the Intl. Journal of Engineering Science)
Robin J. Knops and Amit Acharya
The relationship between dislocation theory and the difference of linear elastic solutions for two different sets of elastic moduli, derived by Filon in two-dimensions, is generalised to three-dimensions. Essential features are developed and illustrated by the examples of the edge and screw dislocations. The inhomogeneity problem is discussed within the same context and related to Somigliana dislocations, and in the limit to the interstitial atom.
On an equation from the theory of field dislocation mechanics
Submitted by Amit Acharya on Thu, 2011-03-03 20:07.(Paper to appear in Bollettino della Unione Matematica Italiana - Bulletin of the Italian Mathematical Union)
Luc Tartar and Amit Acharya
Global existence and uniqueness results for a quasilinear system of partial differential equations in one space dimension and time representing the transport of dislocation density are obtained. Stationary solutions of the system are also studied, and an infinite dimensional class of equilibria is derived. These time (in)dependent solutions include both periodic and aperiodic spatial distributions of smooth fronts of plastic distortion representing dislocation twist boundary microstructure. Dominated by hyperbolic transport-like features and at the same time containing a large class of equilibria, our system differs qualitatively from regularized systems of hyperbolic conservation laws and neither does it fit into a gradient flow structure.
Characterization of residual stress fields in nonlinear elasticity; a question posed by Sebastien Turcaud
Submitted by Amit Acharya on Wed, 2010-12-22 15:07.In the post
http://www.imechanica.org/node/9509
Sebastien Turcaud asks the question (my interpretation) of the characterization of all possible residual elastic distortion fields on a given configuration (interpreted as the current configuration). If one in addition introduces a reference configuration then the deformation gradient w.r.t. this reference is known and depending upon how one defines 'eigendeformation' in nonlinear elasticity, corresponding eigendformation fields to the residual elastic distortion fields can be determined. Such eigendeformation fields can contain fields arising from plastic deformation, non-uniform thermal expansion etc.
- 4 comments
- Read more
- 2232 reads
Microcanonical Entropy and Mesoscale Dislocation Mechanics and Plasticity
Submitted by Amit Acharya on Tue, 2010-11-09 02:34.(Journal of Elasticity, Carlson memorial Volume)
A methodology is devised to utilize the statistical mechanical entropy of an isolated, constrained atomistic system to define the dissipative driving-force and energetic fields in continuum thermomechanics. A thermodynamic model of dislocation mechanics is discussed. One outcome is a definition for the mesoscale back-stress tensor and the symmetric, polar dislocation density-dependent, Cauchy stress tensor from atomistic ingredients.
Professor Donald E. Carlson
Submitted by Amit Acharya on Wed, 2010-08-25 12:36.It is with great sadness that I report the passing away of Prof. Don Carlson. The link below describes his life and work.
http://mechse.illinois.edu/content/news/article.php?article_id=410
- 2 comments
- 1901 reads
Continuum Mechanics of Line Defects in Liquid Crystals and Liquid Crystal Elastomers
Submitted by Amit Acharya on Fri, 2010-04-09 19:26.
This paper presents a generalization of traditional continuum approaches to liquid crystals and
liquid crystal elastomers to allow for dynamically evolving line defect distributions. In analogy with
recent mesoscale models of dislocations, we introduce fields that represent defects in orientational
and positional order through the incompatibility of the director and deformation ‘gradient’ fields.
Case Studies in Mesoscale Field Dislocation Mechanics
Submitted by Amit Acharya on Fri, 2010-01-08 16:52.(in Computational Methods for Microstructure-Property Relationships," Springer. Edited by Somnath Ghosh and Dennis Dimiduk)
Dislocation mediated continuum plasticity: case studies on modeling scale dependence, scale-invariance, and directionality of sharp yield-point
Claude Fressengeas, Amit Acharya, Armand Beaudoin
Wave solutions for a quasilinear model of Field Dislocation Mechanics
Submitted by Amit Acharya on Wed, 2009-12-30 20:18.(in Journal of the Mechanics and Physics of Solids)
Johannes Zimmer, Karsten Matthies, Amit Acharya
We consider an exact reduction of a model of Field Dislocation Mechanics to a scalar problem in one spatial dimension and investigate the existence of static and slow, rigidly moving single or collections of planar screw dislocation walls in this setting. Two classes of drag coefficient functions are considered, namely those with linear growth near the origin and those with constant or more generally sublinear growth there. A mathematical characterisation of all possible equilibria of these screw wall microstructures is given. We also prove the existence of travelling wave solutions for linear drag coefficient functions at low wave speeds and rule out the existence of nonconstant bounded travelling wave solutions for sublinear drag coefficients functions. It turns out that the appropriate concept of a solution in this scalar case is that of a viscosity solution. The governing equation is not proper and it is shown that no comparison principle holds. The findings indicate a short-range nature of the stress field of the individual dislocation walls, which indicates that the nonlinearity present in the model may have a stabilising effect.
- 3 comments
- Read more
- 2255 reads
New inroads in an old subject: plasticity, from around the atomic to the macroscopic scale
Submitted by Amit Acharya on Tue, 2009-08-04 17:20.(in Journal of the Mechanics and Physics of Solids)
Nonsingular, stressed, dislocation (wall) profiles are shown to be 1-d equilibria of a non-equilibrium theory of Field Dislocation Mechanics (FDM). It is also shown that such equilibrium profiles corresponding to a given level of load cannot generally serve as a traveling wave profile of the governing equation for other values of nearby constant load; however, one case of soft loading with a special form of the dislocation velocity law is demonstrated to have no ‘Peierls barrier’ in this sense. The analysis is facilitated by the formulation of a 1-d, scalar, time-dependent, Hamilton-Jacobi equation as an exact special case of the full 3-d FDM theory accounting for non-convex elastic energy, small, Nye-tensor dependent core energy, and possibly an energy contribution based on incompatible slip. Relevant nonlinear stability questions, including that of nucleation, are formulated in a non-equilibrium setting. Elementary averaging ideas show a singular perturbation structure in the evolution of the (unsymmetric) macroscopic plastic distortion, thus pointing to the possibility of predicting generally rate-insensitive slow response constrained to a tensorial ‘yield’ surface, while allowing fast excursions off it, even though only simple kinetic assumptions are employed in the microscopic FDM theory. The emergent small viscosity on averaging that serves as the small parameter for the perturbation structure is a robust, almost-geometric consequence of large gradients of slip in the dislocation core and the persistent presence of a large number of dislocations in the averaging volume. In the simplest approximation, the macroscopic yield criterion displays anisotropy based on the microscopic dislocation line and Burgers vector distribution, a dependence on the Laplacian of the incompatible slip tensor and a nonlocal term related to a Stokes-Helmholtz-curl projection of an ‘internal stress’ derived from the incompatible slip energy.
- 3 comments
- Read more
- 2594 reads
Notes on Implicit Update for Bergstrom-Boyce Network B
Submitted by Amit Acharya on Fri, 2009-03-13 10:10.This post is in response to the imechanica request
http://www.imechanica.org/node/5034
(a separate post, as I have to attach notes - it would be really nice to be able to attach documents to imechanica comments)
Attached are hand-written notes I have used to implement the Network B for the Bergstrom-Boyce model. They were written for my use only, so if it seems stream-of-consciousness at times, don't blame me. The details should all be there, though.
It is a formulation in principal stretches and takes care of the Jacobian in situations with eigenvalue coalescence (double coalescence in part III, triple coalescence in pdf of ppt).
- 2 comments
- Read more
- 2790 reads
Deformation 'Gradient', Right/Left Cauchy Green Compatibility
Submitted by Amit Acharya on Wed, 2008-09-03 11:07.I post some (hand-written) notes on compatibility conditions for both small and finite strains that I have used for helping me in lecturing. These may be useful for our student friends on imechanica. I also post a paper on compatibility conditions for the Left Cauchy-Green field in three dimensions as well as the paper by Janet Blume on the same subject.
- 9 comments
- Read more
- 7596 reads
Geometric Dislocation tensor in finite plasticity
Submitted by Amit Acharya on Thu, 2008-05-08 18:10.The criteria of Cermelli and Gurtin (2001, J. Mech. Phys. Solids) for choosing a geometric dislocation tensor in finite plasticity are reconsidered. It is shown that physically reasonable alternate criteria could just as well be put forward to select other measures; overall, the emphasis should be on the connections between various physically meaningful measures as is customary in continuum mechanics and geometry, rather than on criteria to select one or another specific measure.
- 6 comments
- Read more
- 4467 reads
Void expansion as wave phenomena - might damage evolution be mathematically related to fluid dynamics and turbulence?
Submitted by Amit Acharya on Sat, 2008-03-22 04:56.The main idea is the following: a most natural mathematical setup for considering the motion of the void-solid interface of an expanding void is that of the traveling wave. Thus, a theory for macroscopic damage evolution may be suspected as being a homogenized version of basic theory that has such wave phenomena as an essential ingredient. This paper is a first step in probing such questions.
Science, as some see it...
Submitted by Amit Acharya on Sat, 2007-11-17 18:30.I came across some content I used to have on my webpage a long time ago.
http://www.ce.cmu.edu/~amita/webpage_misc.html
Hopefully it is inspirational for that bright, young, graduate student waiting in the wings to usher in the revolution that shows us how to solve some of the outstanding theoretical problems of solid mechanics that we seem to put off e.g. concrete, quantitative methods for calculating time-dependent microstructure in plasticity and its effect on time-dependent macroscopic properties.....
For those who read the link, do not miss Faraday's quote and Rota's "Ten lessons...'
- 3 comments
- 2304 reads
Musings on continuum thermodynamic formalism and (yet another) damage model
Submitted by Amit Acharya on Mon, 2007-10-01 21:18.A technique for setting up generalized continuum theories based on a balance law and nonlocal thermodynamics is suggested. The methodology does not require the introduction of gradients of the internal variable in the free energy. Elements of a generalized damage model with porosity as the internal variable are developed as an example.
New perspectives in plasticity theory
Submitted by Amit Acharya on Mon, 2007-10-01 21:05.
A field theory of dislocation mechanics and plasticity is illustrated through new results at the nano, meso, and macro scales. Specifically, dislocation nucleation, the occurrence of wave-type response in quasi-static plasticity, and a jump condition at material interfaces and its implications for analysis of deformation localization are discussed.
- 2 comments
- 3233 reads
Does a radially expanding cylinder bend?
Submitted by Amit Acharya on Tue, 2007-05-15 16:42.The Koiter-Sanders-Budiansky bending strain measure and a nonlinear generalization
We know from strength of materials that non-uniform stretching of fibers along the cross section of a beam produces bending moments. But does this situation necessarily correspond to a 'bending' deformation? For that matter, what do we exactly mean kinematically when we talk about a bending deformation?
To make the question more concrete, consider a cylinder that expands uniformly along all radial rays. Does this deformation of the cylinder correspond to bending? I think it is fair to say that most would say that this is purely a stretching deformation with no bending. But then, what is precisely a bending deformation?
papers related to reply: apparent randomness continues
Submitted by Amit Acharya on Tue, 2007-04-24 20:37.Two papers are attached related to randomness discussion.
Toward averaging nonlinear dynamics
Submitted by Amit Acharya on Sat, 2007-04-07 22:07.Attached is a paper outlining ideas for averaging autonomous dynamics, based on a dynamical systems point of view.
People interested in computational multiscale modeling, especially of the sequential kind, as well as nonequilibrium statistical mechanics may find these ideas useful.


Recent comments
3 min 9 sec ago
4 hours 12 min ago
4 hours 37 min ago
7 hours 46 min ago
8 hours 3 min ago
8 hours 6 min ago
8 hours 7 min ago
8 hours 39 min ago
8 hours 50 min ago
9 hours 46 min ago